Wisdom, sleeping..
  • Home
  • Four Pillars of Wisdom
    • Why Wisdom, a Provisional Foreword
    • Doubts
    • Ethos or How I Learned Some Wisdom
    • The "State of the Art" - an impression
    • A Nutshell History of Worldly Wisdom
    • What is Wisdom?
    • The first pillar of wisdom: wise knowledge
    • Good Judgment is the second pillar of wisdom
    • Wise Conduct is the third pillar of wisdom
  • Articles
    • Secret Life of the Obvious
    • Powerful inaction, conspicuous absence, bountiful void
    • The Power to Make Things Simple
    • Three kinds of Criticism
    • Critical thinking is disobedient, not correct
    • Strategy of Surprise
    • The Rectification of Meaning
    • The n plus minus one principle: higher, wider, different...
    • The Fascination of Paradox
    • A choice of choices
    • Des choix de la spiritualité
  • Blog
  • This reminds me of a story

Don’t do the wrong thing right

15/8/2011

3 Comments

 
PicturePeacock pride - Pearson Scott Foresman PD Wikimedia


 
 Don’t do the wrong thing right. “The thing well done” must be a good one.

 Do the undeserving things which you are forced to do, as they deserve, poorly.

The nineteenth and twentieth century created a general belief that people are on Earth to work. The punishing injunction of Genesis* “In the sweat of thy face shalt thou eat bread, till thou return unto the ground” got skilfully translated into a doctrine of Economy, Morals and pillar of Human Society. This forced us all to find dignity in the work we do, educated without much discussion that we live to work and our life finds meaning in work. Do your job, discharge your function! Give the other man hell! Work, so goes the unquestioned axiom, gives meaning to your life! Another sort of opium for the people, leisure-class excepted, (in times when human labour is less and less necessary in abundant, productive societies). It followed “naturally” that all work must be well done, whatever it may happen to be. 
 


Think again: Is that so? Is it so? Always?
 
Many a fool serves with his competence, energy and a fever of proud perfectionism some stupid industry, wrong cause or a guilty ultimate aim that should be left to fail and rot.
 
Many of us labour, often against our best interest and values, while covering our face with words like duty, contracts, loyalty and excellence or because everybody else around us are pressing us by competing to do it cheap, fast and best. Instead, we should labour only to survive if we must, work only to live better if we can. So many "sub-optimise" whatever they do even when it results in harming the whole by doing a local part too well, without coordination or perspective. Instead, our creative action, if free,  should achieve things we like and deem noble to do within some vision .

Sadly, we know intuitively that from time to time there is something wrong in the grinding, but we are ashamed or feel guilty if we do not perform our technical task beautifully, at quality standards. We are only following instructions, after all everybody is doing it... As if how you own work could be separated from what you do and who you are.

I indulged this error a long time ago and it caused me useless exertion and the persistent regret of being abused. I still lapse from time to time. I love the thing well done! I admire a "pro". It gives one a (false) sense of self-worth.

How do we get so totally "functional" and taken with doing things properly so that we grow servile and morally blind of the final aims and consequences? Are we mere instruments and cogs? Is Homo Faber just a tool in a society turned machine-like?

I understand that honest persons shall do their task properly, in good faith, worth their pay. I respect the toil to survive and feed a family. I join the ideal of building society together. I also understand that in time you are what you do, so that we need to respect our work in order to respect ourselves. But I make a difference between good work and mindless execution. I hate to see good people excelling in stupid task and see great fault in undertaking that serves questionable, absurd and even wicked business.

One can explain, with disapproval, experts and mercenaries doing their questionable trade well, under pretext of "following orders", for fear, greed, a needed wage; but how to judge the honest, good, enthusiastic, gifted fool who sells himself away by compulsion and pride of the “thing well done”, because he cannot help?

Doing the wrong thing as well as you can   – to prove like a peacock to yourself or to other people how skilled and professional you are - is getting used indeed.
 
We should act as persons, with our own mind and personality. Make choices! Do well the worthy thing and - without much fuss - discharge the poor "jobs" we must perform as well but not better than they deserve. 

PictureOx & frog Source: artist Charles Santore tumblr_2010

When the aims or the end-results are wrong, do not serve them truly, let them fail.

​If in danger, under oppression, undermine them furtively.
​
Except to this when, under strict control, in total lack of freedom to chose, 
from a position of weakness, you still want to oppose the unacceptable. Then, do it by excess of zeal, do more than needed, better than best, pump up the ugly frog to such an exaggeration that it may burst. 



​​Do then as I say not as I erred. Don’t do the wrong thing right.

PictureDead Chicken (This is how the peacock ends) CC BY-NC 2.0 Dr Case 2007 flickr
​_____________________________
 
*(Genesis 3:19 King James Bible)

3 Comments
Daniel Tenner link
16/8/2011 04:01:35 am

Conversely, another philosophy that seems to work in many cases appears directly opposed. That philosophy is best summarised as "if you're going to do something, do it well."

That of course does not apply to *wrong* things, but perhaps merely to not-the-favourite-choice-right-now types of things.

So, I guess each of those philosophies has value in the right context.

Reply
Craig link
1/1/2014 05:06:39 am

Thank you for an extraordinary site - evidence that there still is intelligent life on Earth. I linked to this page from my blog for particular reasons, but I would recommend that consideration be given to every word Ioan and Daniel have written.
Ioan and Daniel, thank you.
Cheers,
Craig

Reply
Geoffrey
21/5/2017 12:59:47 am

This explains why Trump's White House seems to be so determined to do his bidding so badly.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Categories

    All
    Absence
    Advice
    Aging Parents
    Agree To Disagree
    Akrasia
    Animal Rights
    A Time For Everything
    Axioms
    Bad Silence
    Beast
    Being Wise
    Books
    Carpe Diem
    Choice Of Choices
    Choices
    Communication
    Compassion
    Complexity
    Consulting Difference
    Counsel
    Credibility
    Critical Spirit
    Critical Thinking
    Criticism
    Critique
    Death
    Disenchanters
    Dying For Ideas
    Emptiness
    Error
    Evil
    Expression
    Extremes
    Facts Are Friendly
    Fast Thinking
    Foolishness
    Freedom
    Free Thinking
    Free Will
    Friendly Criticism
    Future
    Gatherer Attitude
    Given And Made
    Golden Rule
    Good Judgement
    Goodness
    Hostile Criticism
    Human Needs
    Humility
    Impossible
    Intangibles
    Intelligent Stupidity
    Intuition
    Justice
    Kindness
    Knowing People
    Learning From History
    Leaving The Table
    Life
    Listening
    Locus Of Control
    Losing With Grace
    Making Things Simple
    Measure Of All Things
    Moderation
    Montaigne
    Motivation
    N±1
    Nasreddin Hodja
    Need To Know Everything
    Not Doing
    Not Knowing
    Objective Criticism
    Obvious
    One Truth
    Out Of The Box
    Owning Your Words
    Paradox
    Parting
    Peace
    Point Of View
    Power
    Preparing Against Surprise
    Preparing For Surprise
    Preparing The Surprise
    Pride
    Progress
    Promise Of Science
    Protagoras Of Abdera
    Readers
    Reciprocity
    Rectification Of Meaning
    Religion
    Representation
    Resilience
    Respect
    Right To Be Wrong
    Right To Error
    Rite Of Separation
    Science
    Seekers And Finders
    Shapes
    Signs Of The Beast
    Silence
    Simple People
    Sincerity
    Sleeping Wisdom
    Small Wheel
    Socratic Method
    Spontaneous Thinking
    Strategy
    Stupidity
    Subtlety
    Surprise
    The King Is Naked
    Theodicy
    Three Kinds Of Criticism
    Too Big Too Small
    Truth
    Uncertainty
    Use Of Error
    Values
    Void
    What Happens To Me
    Why Memories
    Wisdom
    Wisdom Of Ends
    Wisdom Of Means
    Wrong Thing Right

    RSS Feed

© 2011 - 2020 Ioan Tenner & Daniel Tenner